Why Pie Is Better Than Cake






image for why is pie better than cake

Pie vs Cake: The Great Debate

When it comes to dessert, the debate between pie and cake is never-ending. While both are delicious options, there are several reasons why pie is better than cake. From the crust to the filling, a good pie can satisfy your sweet tooth in ways that a cake just can’t match.

The Crust

One of the biggest reasons why pie is better than cake is because of its crust. A good crust can make or break a pie, and when it’s done right, it’s simply irresistible. Whether you prefer a flaky pastry or a crumbly graham cracker crust, there’s something about the texture and flavor of a well-made crust that sets pies apart from cakes.


Another reason why pies are superior to cakes is because they’re incredibly versatile. While cakes come in all shapes and sizes, they’re often limited in terms of their flavors and toppings. Pies, on the other hand, offer endless possibilities when it comes to fillings and toppings.

From classic fruit pies like apple or cherry to savory options like chicken potpie or shepherd’s pie – there’s no shortage of variety when it comes to pies.

Portion Control

One issue with cakes is that they’re often too big for one person – leading us down an unhealthy path towards overeating! Fortunately for those who love desserts but want to avoid consuming excess amounts of sugar (or want an excuse for seconds), pies offer an easy solution: portion control.

A slice of pie typically has fewer calories than an equally sized piece of cake because less frosting (if any) covers each serving size; therefore making cutting back on calories easier while still satisfying your sweet tooth!


Texture plays an essential role in any good dessert experience – especially concerning how soft versus crunchy something feels on our tongues! Pie wins out again here thanks mainly due its diverse ingredients ranging from fruits to nuts, custards to creams, and all of the textures they create.

Cakes have a more uniform texture, which can become monotonous after a few bites. Pies’ textures make for an enjoyable and exciting eating experience that keeps you coming back for more.


For many people, pies represent tradition and nostalgia. From holiday celebrations to family gatherings, pie has been a staple dessert in American culture for generations. Whether it’s grandma’s homemade apple pie or a classic pecan pie at Thanksgiving dinner – there’s something about the smell and taste of a well-made pie that brings back memories of simpler times.

The Versatility of Pie

One of the biggest advantages that pie has over cake is its versatility. From sweet to savory, hot or cold – pies can be enjoyed in many different forms. Here are a few reasons why pie’s versatility makes it a superior dessert option.

Pie is a versatile dessert option that offers a variety of flavors, textures, and filling options. Its flaky, buttery crust, fruit fillings, and ability to be served both warm and cold make it a healthier dessert choice compared to other sugary treats. With its rich history and constant evolution, pie continues to reign supreme in the dessert world.

Sweet Pies

When most people think of pies, they likely think of sweet fruit pies like apple, cherry, or blueberry. These classic desserts offer a perfect balance between tart and sweet flavors and are often accompanied by a flaky crust that adds texture and depth to each bite.

However, the sweetness of pies doesn’t have to stop at fruit fillings. Other popular sweet pie options include custard-based fillings like pumpkin or pecan – which make for delicious holiday treats – as well as chocolate cream and banana cream pies for those who crave something rich and decadent.

Savory Pies

While sweet pies may be more popular in the United States, savory meat-filled options have been around just as long! Shepherd’s pie is one such example – made with ground lamb (or beef), vegetables like carrots & peas baked under mashed potatoes topping making it an entire meal on its own!

Another classic savory pie dish is potpie – filled with meat such as chicken or beef along with vegetables such as peas & carrots all coated in gravy which gives this dish its signature flavor profile.

Fried Pies

Fried foods may not always be healthy but they sure do taste good! Fried fruit turnovers are similar to traditional baked fruit tarts but feature a crispy fried pastry shell instead. These handheld treats can be found at fairs and carnivals across America where their portable nature makes them easy to eat while walking around enjoying other attractions!

Savory fried hand-pies also exist in Southern cuisine culture where these handheld pockets are filled with meats such as pork sausage or crawfish along with cheese making them an excellent on-the-go snack whenever you’re in need of a satisfying meal.

Ice Cream Pies

For those who love both pie and ice cream, what could be better than combining the two? Ice cream pies are a great summer dessert option that can be customized to suit your tastes. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to more unique options like peanut butter cup or mint chocolate chip – there’s an ice cream pie for everyone!

Ice cream pies can also incorporate other ingredients like cookie crumbs, nuts, and fruit which makes them even more delicious. Best of all – they don’t require any baking, so they’re perfect for hot summer days when you don’t want to heat up the kitchen.

Gluten-Free & Vegan Pies

With more people adopting gluten-free or vegan lifestyles these days, it’s essential that desserts cater to their specific dietary restrictions as well! Fortunately, there are many different gluten-free and vegan pie options available. Some popular recipes use almond flour or coconut flour instead of wheat flour for the crust while others use fruit purees or vegetable fillings in place of dairy products.

The History of Pie: A Delicious Evolution

Pie has been a beloved dessert for centuries, and its history is as rich and diverse as its flavors. From ancient civilizations to modern-day bakeries, the evolution of pie is a fascinating journey that highlights the importance of this dessert in cultures around the world.

Pies offer a versatile, delicious, and healthier dessert option compared to other treats. Pies can be sweet or savory, use fresh and high-quality ingredients, offer portion control, and provide nutritional variations depending on the filling and crust used. Plus, who can resist the perfect flaky crust?

Early Beginnings

While pies have been enjoyed for thousands of years, their earliest form was likely more savory than sweet. In ancient Egypt, meat pies were often made with honey-sweetened fillings and used as offerings to the gods. Similarly, Greeks enjoyed meat-filled pastries called “artocreas” which were often eaten at weddings or other celebrations.

However, it wasn’t until medieval times in Europe that fruit pies began to emerge as a popular dessert option – with fruit being an abundant resource during these times.

Pies in England

England has played an essential role in pie’s evolution over time! During medieval times’ era when pies became popular among nobility class where they were filled with meats such as veal or pork along with dried fruits like raisins or currants which gave these dishes their unique flavor profile.

In the 16th century, apple pie became a national symbol of England! It was even mentioned by name in William Shakespeare’s plays like “The Merry Wives of Windsor.” By this point apple filling had become standardised but there are still many regional variations throughout England today!

American Pies

Pies played an integral part during Thanksgiving since early colonial days – pumpkin & pecan quickly becoming go-to options during this holiday season!

One interesting fact about American pies is that they helped facilitate westward expansion by providing pioneers with portable food sources. Pioneers would create dried fruit “shaker” pies by filling crusts with chopped apples & other fruits before drying them out so they could be taken on long journeys without spoiling!

During World War II when sugar rationing was at its highest point, pies became even more popular as they provided a way to indulge in something sweet without using up precious sugar supplies! Apple pies were especially popular during this time due to their abundance of fresh apples.

Modern-Day Pies

Today, pie continues to evolve with modern-day bakers creating new and exciting flavors that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth!

One trend that has emerged in recent years is the use of savory ingredients like bacon or cheese in pie fillings. This adds a unique twist on traditional sweet pies and provides a delicious balance between salty and sweet.

Another trend is the use of non-traditional crusts such as pretzel or cookie crusts. These alternative crusts provide an extra layer of flavor and texture that can take any pie recipe to the next level!

Finally, there has been an increase in gluten-free and vegan pie options in recent years, allowing those with dietary restrictions or preferences to enjoy this beloved dessert option without worry!

The Science Behind Pie’s Perfect Crust

A good crust is essential for any delicious pie. Whether it’s flaky and buttery or crumbly and sweet, the perfect crust requires a combination of science and artistry to achieve. Here are some key factors that contribute to the science behind pie’s perfect crust.

Pie is a superior dessert option compared to cake due to its variety of flavors and textures, the ability to serve warm or cold, and its aesthetic appeal. Pies are also highly versatile and can be sweet or savory, fried, or even made into ice cream pies. The evolution of pie is fascinating and has been a beloved dessert for centuries. Plus, choosing pie as a dessert option can be a healthier choice with its fruit fillings, control over ingredients, and portion control options.

Fat Content

One of the most critical components for creating a great pie crust is fat – typically butter or lard. In addition to providing flavor, fat plays an important role in texture by creating layers in the dough when baked.

When fat is mixed into flour, it coats each individual grain – preventing gluten from developing too much which can lead to toughness instead of flakiness! The more fat used in a recipe, the more tender & flaky your final outcome will be!

Flour Type

The type of flour used when making pie dough also affects its end result. All-purpose flour is commonly used due to its versatility but pastry flour with lower protein content may produce even better results with less gluten formation leading up to a crumbly texture that pairs well with pies!

Gluten-free options have also become increasingly popular these days as people look for ways to accommodate dietary restrictions without sacrificing taste or quality ingredients.

Temperature Control

Temperature control plays an important role in creating a perfect pie crust! Cold ingredients are key when it comes down getting right consistency during mixing process before baking begins!

Pie dough should always be chilled after mixing so that fats remain solidified until they’re baked into their desired shape & form which ensures structure while baking process takes place!

Another important temperature factor has to do with oven heat – preheating your oven before putting your pies inside ensures proper heat distribution which sets up excellent conditions for achieving beautiful golden-brown finishes on top of each slice served later on!

Proper Mixing Technique

Proper technique when mixing ingredients together is essential when making any type of pastry including pies! Overworking the dough can lead to toughness but not enough mixing can leave it too crumbly.

One popular method is to mix the ingredients together until just combined, then let the dough rest for 30 minutes before rolling it out. This allows time for gluten strands to relax and makes dough easier to work with less chance of tearing or cracking!

Moisture Content

Moisture content is another important factor in creating a perfect pie crust. Too little moisture and your crust will crumble, too much and it will be tough.

Adding water or other liquids gradually & slowly while mixing ensures best results that are consistent and delicious!

Blind Baking

Blind baking (pre-baking a pastry shell before filling) helps ensure that your pie crust stays flaky and doesn’t turn soggy from wet fillings like fruit pies! There are many reasons why you might choose blind baking – ranging from preventing undercooked bottoms on custard-type pies through reducing excessive liquid seeping into the pastry base of savory meat-filled options.

Pie: A Healthier Dessert Option

While desserts are often associated with indulgence and excess, pie can be a healthier dessert option compared to other decadent treats. Here are some reasons why choosing pie over other desserts can be a better choice for your health.

Fruit Fillings

One of the biggest advantages of pies is that they’re often made with fruit fillings. Fruits like apples, berries, and cherries are rich in vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants that provide numerous health benefits. Eating more fruits has been linked to:

  • Lower risk of chronic diseases like heart disease, diabetes & cancer.
  • Reduced inflammation in the body.
  • Improved digestion & bowel movements thanks to fiber content.

While it’s true that sugar is still present in many fruit-fillings – making sure you get the right balance between natural sugars from these fruits along with added sugars will help maintain healthy blood sugar levels.

Control Over Ingredients

When you make your own pies at home or order them from bakeries focused on using fresh ingredients – you have much greater control over what goes into them! This means being able to choose high-quality ingredients that offer real nutritional value instead of empty calories found in processed food alternatives!

Making homemade pie crusts also allows for substitution options such as gluten-free flour and alternative fats such as coconut oil or avocado oil instead of butter which may not only improve nutrient profile but taste equally delicious!

Pies offer an advantage when it comes to portion control options compared to cake where slices tend to be much larger! A single slice of pie typically contains fewer calories than an extra-large piece of cake while still providing an enjoyable sweet treat experience which satisfies our cravings without overindulging our appetites!

If you’re looking for smaller portions or serving sizes cut down on servings per batch by baking individual mini-pies – perfect for sharing during holiday gatherings without sacrificing any flavor experiences we all love!

Nutritional Variations

Pies offer a lot of nutritional variations depending on the type of filling and crust used. For example:

  • Nut pies made with pecans or almonds are rich in healthy fats and protein which keep you full for longer periods.
  • Pumpkin pies offer a great source of Vitamin A, potassium, & fiber.
  • Sweet potato pies contain beta-carotene which is an antioxidant that


Why do some people prefer pie over cake?

Some people may prefer pie over cake because pies tend to have a more complex and interesting texture. A typical pie crust adds a buttery, flaky crunch to the soft and sweet filling, which can create a more satisfying mouthfeel. Additionally, people who enjoy the unique flavor profile of fruits, nuts, or custards may find that pies are a better fit for their taste buds. Lastly, pies are often associated with cozy, homey feelings, making them a perfect dessert for holiday gatherings or family dinners.

What makes pies more versatile than cakes?

Pies are considered by many to be more versatile than cakes for a few reasons. Firstly, pies can be made with a wide variety of fillings, ranging from sweet to savory. This allows them to be served as a dessert, main course, or even breakfast dish. Secondly, pies can be baked or no-bake, meaning they can be made in hot or cold weather. Lastly, pies can be made in different sizes, making them customizable for individual servings or larger crowds.

Why are pies sometimes considered healthier than cakes?

When compared to cakes, pies can be considered healthier in some ways. First and foremost, pies tend to showcase fresh fruit, which is a great source of vitamins, minerals, and fiber. Additionally, many pie recipes use less sugar than cake recipes and may not require frosting, cutting back on added sugars and artificial ingredients. Finally, some pie crusts can be made with healthier fats like olive oil or coconut oil, while cake recipes often call for butter and heavy cream.

What are some cultural and historical reasons why pies are so beloved?

Pies are a beloved dessert worldwide and hold a special place in many cultures, for example, the British are especially fond of meat pies. Historically, pies have their roots in ancient civilizations in Egypt and Greece and were often used as a way to preserve food. In medieval times, pies were popular among the upper class. Later, American pioneers used pies as a convenient way to transport fruit and other ingredients while traveling westward. Today, pies continue to be a symbol of tradition, comfort, and shared memories for many people.

Jessica Hartley

Share this


How to Make Ginger and Cinnamon Tea

Ginger and cinnamon tea is a delicious and healthy beverage that is easy to prepare and can be enjoyed any time of day. This...

Is Natural Bliss Coffee Creamer Healthy?

<img src="https://images.pexels.com/photos/4424672/pexels-photo-4424672.jpeg?auto=compress&cs=tinysrgb&h=350" alt="image for is Natural Bliss coffee creamer healthy" style="width:100%;"> Coffee can be a morning ritual for many individuals. Whether you brew it at...

Do You Refrigerate Dump Cake?

Dump cake is a beloved dessert in many households due to its simplicity and versatility in flavor. However, one question that often arises when...

Recent articles

More like this


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here